Request for Proposals: Clark & Floyd Counties Attainable Housing Coalition

Date Issued: 11/6/2026 | Responses Due: 12/11/2026
Table of Contents
- Introduction
- Background
- Role of the Backbone Organization
- Expectations of the Selected Organization
- Resources and Sustainability
- RFP Important Dates
- Evaluation Process
- Criteria for Consideration
- RFP Response Requirements
- Submittal Instructions & Inquires
- Terms & Conditions
- Responses to All Eligible Inquiries
Introduction
The Community Foundation of Southern Indiana (hereafter CFSI) is seeking proposals from qualified and interested organizations to serve as the backbone organization for the Clark & Floyd Counties Attainable Housing Strategic Plan. The selected organization will assume long-term leadership and coordination of a regional effort to increase the supply of housing attainable to households earning 50%–80% of Area Median Income (AMI) in Clark and Floyd Counties, Indiana. This role is intended to carry the plan’s 10-year vision forward and to sustain the work beyond it.
Over the past several years, CFSI and its partners have laid the groundwork for this effort. This work includes research defining the region’s housing affordability challenge, a Housing Community Advisory Board that engages leaders from across both counties, a 10-year strategic plan now in development, and early implementation work that is already moving attainable housing projects forward. CFSI believes the effort now requires a dedicated organization to convene partners, align their activities around a shared agenda, measure and report progress, and mobilize the resources needed to succeed over the long term.
Background
The Regional Housing Challenge
In partnership with the Indiana University Southeast Applied Research and Education Center (hereafter AREC), and with funding from Lilly Endowment Inc., CFSI commissioned the report Housing: The Affordability Challenge in a Growing Region, which examined the structural dynamics of income and the housing market across Clark and Floyd Counties. The report found that housing cost burdens are widespread: more than half of renters in Clark County and 42% of renters in Floyd County spend more than 30% of their income on housing, and nearly 7,000 households across the two counties spend 50% or more of their monthly earnings on housing. The report also identified low vacancy rates and resistance to middle-income and multi-unit housing as key factors shaping the local market.
These pressures fall heavily on households earning 50%–80% of AMI, including teachers, healthcare workers, tradespeople, and other members of the local workforce, who often earn too much to qualify for deeply subsidized programs but too little to compete in the region’s market-rate housing. Because Clark and Floyd Counties are part of the Louisville Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA), AMI thresholds for this effort are based on the Louisville MSA.
Building on Research
Following the report’s release, CFSI committed resources to move from research to action through two parallel efforts as part of a three-year engagement:
- Strategic Planning – AREC is working with the Housing Community Advisory Board (hereafter CAB) to develop a 10-year Attainable Housing Strategic Plan to guide, direct, and measure the region’s efforts to produce more attainable housing.
- Implementation – The Wheatley Group (hereafter TWG) is pursuing near-term implementation by identifying and evaluating development sites, assembling incentive and programmatic support, and matching development opportunities with developers, with a goal of facilitating at least 100 housing units attainable to households earning 50%–80% of AMI.
Both engagements will end on or before December 31, 2027. As the strategic plan nears completion and early implementation continues, CFSI is seeking a permanent home for this effort: an organization that will take ownership of the plan and lead its implementation over the coming decade and beyond.
The Housing Community Advisory Board
The CAB brings together municipalities, nonprofits, lenders, developers, educators, and community leaders from across Clark and Floyd Counties. Its work has been organized through five committees, each focused on a different lever for increasing the supply of attainable housing, and each of which is contributing directly to the strategic plan.
The Attainable Housing Strategic Plan
The strategic plan will serve as the common agenda for this effort and the primary framework the selected organization will implement. The plan is currently under development and is expected to be released at a later date. In its current draft form, the plan is organized around the following five goals, which remain subject to refinement as the plan is finalized:
| Goal | Focus |
| Community Education | A sustained public education campaign to build political and community buy-in for attainable housing. |
| Regulatory Reform | Identify and reduce local regulatory barriers while preserving protections for quality, health, and safety. |
| Capital, Financing & Property | Increase capital, financing tools, and property available to develop and preserve attainable housing. |
| Workforce & Developer Pipeline | Build a reliable pipeline of housing professionals and lower barriers for small-scale developers. |
| 50-80% AMI Buyer Pipeline | A coordinated system that prepares households for homeownership and connects ready buyers to attainable homes. |
Role of the Backbone Organization
This effort is organized around the collective impact model, in which partners across sectors work toward a common agenda that no single organization could achieve alone. Experience with this model has shown that these efforts depend on a dedicated backbone organization to coordinate and sustain the work over time. The selected organization will take over stewardship of the regional attainable housing effort and lead implementation of the 10-year strategic plan. This is intended as an ongoing, long-term role.
Eligible Respondents
Many types of organizations can serve effectively as a backbone, including existing nonprofits, newly formed organizations (under certain circumstances), government entities, funders, and partnerships of multiple organizations. All such entities are eligible to respond to this RFP, however organizations with at least 2 years of continuous operation after obtaining their 501c3 designation are preferred. Existing organizations that have the preferred minimum two-year operational timeframe that create a new partnership in response to this RFP would meet the preference. Each type of structure carries its own strengths and challenges, and respondents should identify their proposed structure and detail how they will address challenges such as perceived neutrality and clear accountability.
Core Functions
CFSI envisions the backbone organization performing six core functions, adapted below to the work in Clark and Floyd Counties.
1. Guide Vision and Strategy
Serve as the steward of the strategic plan by building a common understanding of the problem, prioritizing opportunities for action, and ensuring the plan is updated as conditions change and strategies unfold.
2. Support Aligned Activities
Convene and facilitate the partners, committees, or working groups that carry out the plan’s goals; coordinate action across organizations, municipalities, and both counties; and seek alignment with related efforts in the region.
3. Establish Shared Measurement Practices
Collect, analyze, and report data on progress toward the plan’s measures of success, including attainable units produced; build on existing data tools and dashboards; and publish progress publicly, at least annually.
4. Cultivate Community Engagement and Ownership
Build broad public understanding of and support for attainable housing (Goal 1), produce and manage communications, and engage residents in the effort.
5. Advance Policy
Stay informed on local and state policy affecting housing development, and support partners and local governments in advancing the regulatory and policy changes identified in the plan (Goal 2).
6. Mobilize Resources
Mobilize and align public and private resources in support of the plan’s goals (Goal 3), including resources needed to sustain the backbone itself, and support partners’ efforts to secure funding for attainable housing.
What the Backbone Does Not Do
A backbone organization supports the collective effort; it does not replace it. The backbone does not set the agenda on its own but builds and maintains focus around a common agenda shaped by its partners and the community. It does not independently determine solutions but supports partners as they align their own work with the plan. It also does not receive all resources directed to the effort, as funding for housing development, programs, and services will continue to flow to the partners who deliver them.
Advisory Structure
The selected organization will have flexibility to determine how it engages and guides a stakeholder advisory body moving forward. It may choose to continue working with the existing CAB, restructure it, or establish a new advisory structure. Respondents should detail their proposed approach in their response.
Expectations of the Selected Organization
CFSI recognizes that organizations of many types and sizes may be well suited to this role. The following minimum expectations must be met, or a clear plan to meet them must be provided for any proposal to be considered for selection:
- Long-Term Commitment – Commit to serving as the backbone organization on an ongoing basis. This role is not limited to a fixed term and the organization must demonstrate how they will make this work sustainable.
- Regional Scope – Serve the full geographic footprint of Clark and Floyd Counties and the municipalities within them.
- Dedicated Capacity – Dedicate staff time specifically to the backbone role, rather than adding these responsibilities on top of existing duties.
- Fiscal Capacity – Have the legal and financial capacity to receive, manage, and account for grant and partner funds, either directly or through an identified fiscal agent.
- Public Reporting – Produce a public report on progress toward the strategic plan’s measures of success at least annually.
In addition to the minimum expectations listed above, the following will also be considered when evaluating any proposal:
- Local Presence – Very strong preference will be given to organizations based in, or with an established operating presence in, Clark and Floyd Counties. Organizations without a local presence are not excluded but should detail how they will establish one.
- Trusted Convener – Relationships across sectors and levels of leadership, and the credibility and perceived neutrality needed to bring partners together.
- Housing and Community Development Knowledge – Understanding of housing finance, development, policy, and the needs of 50%–80% AMI households.
- Data Capacity – The ability to manage shared data and use it transparently to guide decisions.
- Fund Development – A track record of securing resources, and a commitment to raising funds for the effort as a whole, not only for the organization.
Transition and Continuity
The selected organization will be expected to assume responsibility for the effort as the current strategic planning and implementation engagements begin to wrap up, as early as January 1, 2027. This includes building on the work completed to date, such as the strategic plan, existing measures and data, development opportunities in progress, and relationships with partners, so that momentum is maintained through the transition. Respondents should carefully consider and detail how this transition will be accomplished.
Resources and Sustainability
At this time, no dedicated funding has been identified to support backbone operations. Respondents are therefore asked to propose an operating budget and a funding approach, which may include existing organizational resources, in-kind contributions, partner support, and grant or philanthropic funding the respondent intends to pursue. Resources available to support this effort may evolve over time, and the selected organization will be encouraged to work with partners to identify and secure sustainable funding.
Backbone organizations commonly operate with an executive leader, a facilitator, and a data manager, with staffing and budgets that grow as an initiative matures. CFSI recognizes that many backbones begin with lean staffing and add capacity as resources allow. Respondents are highly encouraged to propose a realistic starting structure, including part-time, shared, or in-kind staffing where appropriate, along with a plan for how capacity will grow over time.
RFP Important Dates
| Issuance of RFP | 11/6/2026 |
| Deadline for Questions from Respondents | 11/20/2026 |
| Responses to Eligible Questions Posted | 11/25/2026 |
| Deadline to Submit Proposal | 12/11/2026 |
| Interviews with Shortlisted Respondents (if needed) | Week of 12/14/2026 |
| Target Date for Recommendation to CFSI | 12/18/2026 |
| Anticipated Start of Backbone Role | 1/31/2027 |
Evaluation Process
Once received, the proposals will be taken under advisement to be evaluated for completion, content, and conformance with this document by a pre-determined selection committee, using the Criteria for Consideration below. The selection committee may invite top-ranked respondents to interview or present their proposals. The proposals will be ranked and a recommendation made by the selection committee to CFSI for selection.
At its discretion, CFSI may reject any proposal submitted. Additionally, CFSI may request additional information from, interview, and negotiate with respondents at its sole discretion.
Criteria for Consideration
The following criteria will be considered when evaluating proposals. Respondents are highly encouraged to address each in their response.
Local Presence & Reach
- Local Presence – an established base in, or operating presence within, Clark and Floyd Counties
- Geographic Scope – capacity to serve the full footprint of Clark and Floyd Counties and their municipalities
- Geographic Levels – ability to connect across neighborhoods, cities and towns, counties, and the state
- Leadership Levels – ability to connect with, understand, and be respected by both mainstream and grassroots leaders
Core Backbone Functions
- Vision – capacity to support a set of big-picture goals across populations, outcomes, and approaches
- Alignment – ability to align efforts under a common agenda, resolve competing priorities, direct resources, and build bridges between groups
- Convening – ability to convene stakeholders across sectors, systems, coalitions, and partnerships
- Strategy & Action – capacity to facilitate strategic planning and coordinate implementation of action plans
- Public Will & Policy – ability to build public will, communicate the agenda effectively, and help advance public policy
- Measurement & Analysis – capacity to use data in a public, transparent way and establish shared measurement systems
Organizational Capacity & Sustainability
- Fund Development – commitment to the funding priorities of the partnership, not just the organization, and a credible budget and sustainability plan
- Staffing – skilled staff with sufficient time dedicated to coordination and alignment
- Organizational Buy-In – a solid fiscal home with an engaged and supportive board and leadership – respondents should provide a letter of support to demonstrate buy-in
- Accountability – a focus on accountability for the organization’s own staff and for the partnership
- Credibility – standing and credibility within the community
Approach
- Leadership – a collaborative approach that facilitates across sectors and shares credit with partners
- Transition & Work Plan – a realistic plan to build on work completed to date and carry the effort through its first years
RFP Response Requirements
All responses should incorporate narratives, tables, organizational charts, and other associated materials, including the items specifically requested below, in order to communicate the proposal to CFSI. Responses should be organized in the order listed below. Responses should be concise and are encouraged to be approximately ten (10) letter-sized pages, with exhibits and attachments excluded from this page count. This is intended as a guideline rather than a strict limit, so that respondents can fully communicate their proposal while keeping responses manageable for review.
Introduction/Cover Page
This page should detail the respondent’s name and mailing address, current legal status and entity type, contact information, and the signature of an authorized representative. The cover page should clearly identify the proposed backbone structure (see Eligible Respondents under Role of the Backbone Organization) and, for joint proposals, the lead organization and all partner organizations.
Organizational Overview and Local Presence
This section should describe the respondent’s mission, history, governance, and current work, as well as its presence and relationships in Clark and Floyd Counties. Respondents without an established local presence should detail how they will establish one, including local staffing, office space, and partnerships.
Understanding of the Effort and Vision
This section should demonstrate the respondent’s understanding of the region’s attainable housing challenge and the strategic plan’s goals as currently drafted and describe the respondent’s vision for the backbone role over the 10-year plan horizon and beyond.
Approach to Backbone Functions
This section should describe how the respondent will carry out each of the six core functions described in this RFP, and how its approach will advance each of the strategic plan’s goals as currently drafted.
Advisory Structure and Partner Engagement
This section should describe the respondent’s proposed approach to engaging and guiding a stakeholder advisory body, whether by continuing with the existing CAB, restructuring it, or establishing a new structure, as well as how it will engage municipalities, partner organizations, and the community. Respondents should also identify and detail how they will address the challenges of their proposed structure, including perceived neutrality and accountability.
Shared Measurement and Accountability
This section should describe how the respondent will collect, manage, and report data on progress toward the plan’s measures of success, build upon existing data tools, and report progress publicly.
Staffing and Leadership
This section should describe the proposed staffing structure for the backbone role, including the number of staff, full-time equivalents, and the roles responsible for leadership, facilitation, and data management. Respondents should identify key staff where known and describe the leadership qualities they will bring to the role.
Budget and Sustainability Plan
This section must include a proposed operating budget for the first three years of the backbone role and detail the respondent’s funding approach, including existing resources, in-kind contributions, partner support, and grants or other funding the respondent intends to pursue. Respondents should describe how staffing and capacity will scale as resources allow and provide evidence of the financial and fiscal management capacity needed to sustain the role.
Transition and Work Plan
This section should describe how the respondent will assume responsibility for the effort and build on the work completed to date and should provide a work plan with key milestones for the first 12 months and an outlook for the first three years. This section should align with the RFP Important Dates section of this document, and if conflicts with these dates are anticipated, that should be detailed in the response.
Experience and References
This section should highlight past and ongoing experience convening multi-sector partnerships, coordinating regional initiatives, or leading housing and community development efforts. At least three references should be provided that can speak to the respondent’s capacity and quality of work.
Attachments
Respondents may include attachments that support, illustrate, or further detail statements made in their response, such as organizational materials, financial information, letters of support, or examples of prior work. Attachments are at the respondent’s discretion and will not count toward the page guideline. Attachments must serve as supporting materials only and should not contain narrative or content responding to the requirements of this RFP. All required response components must be addressed within the body of the response, and narrative content provided in attachments may not be considered during evaluation.
Submittal Instructions & Inquiries
Respondents must submit one (1) electronic copy of their proposal in PDF format, which should include the RFP response and all associated exhibits and attachments. Printed copies are not required. Proposals should be submitted via email with the subject line “Coalition Organization RFP – [Respondent Name]” on or before 4:00 PM on 12/11/2026, directed to:
Linda Speed
President & CEO, Community Foundation of Southern Indiana
lspeed@cfsouthernindiana.com
All inquiries regarding this RFP shall be directed in writing to the contact listed below. Inquiries must be received by the date indicated in the RFP Important Dates section above. Responses to all eligible inquiries will be posted below (direct link: https://www.cfsouthernindiana.com/rfp-attainable-housing-coalition/#inquiries) no later than the date indicated in the RFP Important Dates section, so that all respondents have access to the same information. Inquiry contact information is below:
Jacob Arbital
Director of Planning & Development Services
The Wheatley Group, LLC.
5150 Charlestown Road, Suite 1A
New Albany, IN 41750
(812) 920-4546
jacob@thewheatleygrp.com
Terms and Conditions
- CFSI reserves the right to reject any or all proposals at its sole discretion. CFSI may negotiate with any respondent or any other party. CFSI’s decision will be final.
- CFSI reserves the right to modify, supplement, or withdraw this RFP at any time. Any changes will be communicated to all known respondents and posted alongside responses to eligible inquiries.
- Any proposal must be signed by a duly authorized representative of the respondent. By submitting a proposal, the respondent and the signatory to the proposal certify and verify that the signatory has been duly authorized to commit the respondent to the terms of the proposal.
- Respondents are required to pay for any costs of preparing a proposal, and in no event will CFSI reimburse or be liable to any respondent for costs incurred in preparing or presenting a proposal, including any legal costs. CFSI is not liable for any work or service provided by a respondent prior to the execution of any agreement.
Any and all agreements concerning a proposal shall be governed by the laws of the State of Indiana.
Responses to All Eligible Inquiries
Responses to all eligible inquiries will be posted here no later than the date indicated in the RFP Important Dates section, so that all respondents have access to the same information.